Monday, 14 March 2016

Betrayal: The Crisis in the Catholic Church by The Investigative Staff of the Boston Globe


Paperback:  "Betrayal hangs like a heavy cloud over the Church today.  While we do not presume to judge anyone's relationship with God, there is no doubt that a betrayal of trust is at the heart of the evil in the sexual abuse of children by clergy.  Priests should be trustworthy beyond any shadow of a doubt.  When some have broken that trust, all of us suffer the consequences." - Cardinal Bernard F Law, Archbishop of Boston, 29 March 2002.

This is the true story of how a small group of courageous journalists uncovered child abuse on a vast scale - and held the Catholic Church to account.  Betrayal (2016) is a ground-breaking work of investigative journalism, now brought brilliantly to life on the screen in the major movie Spotlight (2015).

The question of the Church failing to take the issue seriously had surfaced now and then since 1985 when the first big case exploded in Louisiana.  At that time, most of those implicated were ordinary priests.  Later, when the scandal quickly broadened, it ensnared not only the priests but the bishops and cardinals who protected them.

On 31 January 2002, the Boston Globe published a report that sent shockwaves around the world.  Their findings, based on a six-month campaign by the 'Spotlight' investigative team, showed that hundreds of children in Boston had been abused by Catholic priests, and that this horrific pattern of behaviour had been known - and ignored - by the Catholic Church.  Instead of protecting the community it was meant to serve, the Church exploited its powerful influence to protect itself from scandal by engaging in largely successful damage control - and innocent children paid the price.

The problem in Boston was a microcosm of a festering sore on the body of the entire Church.  If to some defenders it seemed like merely a brushfire, it was to others the greatest conflagration to face the Church in generations.  It spread across the North American continent, stretched to Europe, and scandalized Australia and parts of Latin America.

This is the story from beginning to end:  the predatory men who exploited the vulnerable using emotional means, the cabal of senior Church officials who covered up their crimes, the 'hush money' used to buy the victims' silence, the case of Father John Geoghan, who has been sentenced to ten years in prison and whose 130 victims have been awarded $30 million, the survivors who found the strength to tell their story, and the Catholics across the world who were left shocked, angry and betrayed.

This is the story, too, of how they took power back, confronted their Church and called for sweeping change.

The newspaper maintains that the 2000 related civil suits pending against the Church are just the tip of the iceberg.

Pope John Paul II said the sexual abuse of minors by priests was not only an "appalling sin" but a crime.  In 2013, Pope Francis amended Vatican law to make sexual abuse of children a crime.

Updated for release of the Oscar-nominated film Spotlight in 2015, this is a devastating and important exposure of the abuse of power at the highest levels in society.  Betrayal also provides important analyses of what is at stake and what this "crisis of faith" means for Catholics everywhere.  It builds on the extensive reporting The Globe has done.  Some of the interviews and facts were previously reported in the newspaper.  However, much of the reporting is new and the book was written from scratch.  The clergy sexual abuse story is still unfolding - thirteen years after it broke open in 2002 - and it will likely take years before all the facts are known and all the changes it set off are in place.

If there are any heroes in this squalid tale, they are the victims, who found their voice, who found the courage, after years of suffering in silence and isolation, to step into the light and say, as one did, "This happened to me, and this is wrong."   

About the author:  The Boston Globe is an American daily newspaper based in Boston, Massachusetts, and has a distinguished record of public service journalism, including astute political coverage that digs deep into the issues, processes, and personalities that shape America's democracy.  It has been awarded 23 Pulitzer Prizes since 1966 for coverage of the Boston Marathon bombings, for its article "War and Peace in the Nuclear Age", their exposure of political favouritism and conflict of interest by office holders in Somerville, Massachusetts, among others.  The book won the Pulitzer Prize for Public Service.

No comments:

Post a Comment