I thought it is time I read true crime based on a hugely intriguing murder that occurred more than four years ago in the hilltop city of Perugia in the heart of Umbria, Italy. I did not take too much notice of the case when it unfolded. It was not until Amanda Knox made news on television in October 2011, when the Italian court acquitted both her and Raffaele Sollecito of all the charges made against them, including murder, sexual assault and staging a break-in, that I first took more than a slight interest in the case.
Guilty or innocent, I cannot come to a definitive conclusion even after closing the book and putting it away. Why? Because the motive for the murder is not clear. There are no reliable witnesses as far as the case is concerned. There is the lack of DNA, hardly any forensic evidence, conflicting witness statements, a very confusing crime scene and a lot of questions which bore more questions and more questions. Prosecution made it easy for the public to believe that Amanda and Raffaele were linked to the murder due to their odd behaviour - they were photographed kissing - immediately after the crime. However, an important but overlooked fact is that there was no evidence - blood and DNA - that connected Amanda and Raffaele to the crime scene at all.
When top criminal defense investigator, Paul Ciolino, reviewed the pile of evidence, he changed his mind from thinking Amanda Knox was probably guilty to concluding that the prosecution of Amanda was a "police-generated fairy tale and a railroad job from hell". Police corruption of the evidence and crime scene was obvious from the crime-scene videotapes and deemed worthless and inadmissible. There were lies, distortions and innuendo, so much so that the whole case was thrown into disarray. An important discovery was covered up by the police and the prosecutor's office. Certain people became afraid and were induced to keep what they knew to themselves for fear of reprisals.
The only real victim in this four-year saga is Meredith Kercher.
As for the others who were directly or peripherally involved, were they guilty, were they innocent, who knows? Right from the beginning of the book, the flow of the story very clearly points the finger of guilt towards Amanda Knox and if so, why? On the other hand, one can't help but ask whether Meredith had just been unlucky. Perhaps she was at the wrong place at the wrong time. If this were a work of fiction, it would be termed the "perfect murder" and I guess it was "the perfect murder" because the perpetrator was allowed to slip through the fingers of the law. Any booklover who has read anything and everything under the sun will find this book, or more accurately this murder, completely unfathomable. I certainly did. Do read it and decide for yourselves.
Presently, Amanda Knox is back at home in Seattle and has reportedly signed a book deal with HarperCollins worth $4million(!) to tell her side of the events surrounding her initial arrest and conviction, incarceration and the trials that followed. Her book will be out next year ie 2013. Her former boyfriend, Raffaele Sollecito, has followed suit with a book deal with Simon and Schuster's Gallery Books scheduled to come out earlier than Amanda's this autumn. His book will be called Presumed Guilty: My Journey to Hell and Back with Amanda Knox.
From the paperback: John Follain, who covers Italy for The Sunday Times, tells the definitive account of the Meredith Kercher case from her murder to the acquittal of Raffaele Sollecito and Amanda Knox. Shortly after 12.30pm on 2 November 2007, Italian police were called to the Perugia home of 21-year-old British student Meredith Kercher. They found her body on the floor under a beige quilt. Her throat had been cut.
Four days later, the prosecutor jailed Meredith's flatmate American student Amanda Knox, and Raffaele Sollecito, her Italian boyfriend. He also jailed Rudy Guede, an Ivory Coast drifter. Four years later Knox and Sollecito were acquitted amid chaotic scenes in front of the world's media.
Uniquely based on four years of reporting and access to the complete case files, Death in Perugia (2011) takes readers on a riveting journey behind the scenes of the investigation, as John Follain shares the drama of the trials and appeal hearings he lived through. Including exclusive interviews with Meredith's friends and other key sources, Death in Perugia reveals how the Italian dream turned into a nightmare.
John Follain was voted runner-up for the 2006 Paul Foot Award for Campaigning Journalism, and nominated for the 2008 Magazine Journalism Awards for his interview with the Knox family.
Breaking news update (30 January 2014): The Amanda Knox retrial began in September 2013. Today, Amanda Knox and Raffaele Sollecito are found guilty of the murder of Meredith Kercher in 2007, for a second time. Amanda is sentenced to 28 years and 6 months in jail whereas Raffaele received 25 years. The judges ordered that damages should be paid by Amanda and Raffaele to the family of Meredith.

No comments:
Post a Comment