Paperback: Maria Monk (27 June 1816 - summer of 1849) was a Canadian woman whose book Awful Disclosures of Maria Monk, or The Hidden Secrets of a Nun's Life in a Convent Exposed (1836) claimed to expose systematic sexual abuse of nuns and infanticide of the resulting children by Catholic priests in her convent in Montreal. The book became a best-seller.
Awful Disclosures of Maria Monk was published in January 1836. In it, Monk claimed that nuns of the Religious Hospitallers of St Joseph of the Montreal convent of the Hôtel-Dieu, whom she called "the Black Nuns", were forced to have sex with the priests in the seminary next door. The priests supposedly entered the convent through a secret tunnel. If the sexual union produced a baby, it was baptized and then strangled and dumped into a lime pit in the basement. Uncooperative nuns disappeared.
Monk's story contains inconsistencies.
In her account, she stated that there were three convents in Montreal: "1st. The Congregational Nunnery. 2nd. The Black Nunnery, or Convent of Sister Bourgeoise. 3rd. The Grey Nunnery." The Congregational Nuns were the Congregation of Notre Dame of Montreal, founded by Marguerite Bourgeoys, not the Sisters of Charity, as Monk stated at the beginning of her text; the Religious Hospitallers of St Joseph, whose habits were balck but who were not typically called "Black Nuns", operated the Hôtel-Dieu, where Monk claimed that she entered and suffered, and it was not founded by "Sister Bourgeoise"; and it was the Sisters of Charity who were commonly known as the Grey Nuns.
It is known that Maria Monk lived in an asylum in her early years and that one of the nuns mentioned in her story was actually a fellow patient in the asylum. There is some evidence that Maria Monk had suffered a brain injury as a child. One possible result of this alleged injury could be that Monk might have been manipulated, and might not be able to distinguish between fact and fantasy. Another possible result of the alleged injury could be that Monk had little understanding of the devastating result of her claims. It has been suggested, though not proven, that Maria Monk was manipulated into playing a role for profit by her publisher or her ghost writers.
The book has been described as a hoax by some scholars and one of the most formidable books against Nunneries ever published.
This edition (2020) is a reproduction of previous publication of this classic work.
About the author: Maria Monk was born in Dorchester (Saint-Jean-sur-Richelieu), Lower Canada in 1816, daughter of William Monk and Isabella Mills and died in the summer of 1849 at New York.
Maria Monk was a difficult child. According to her mother, when she was about seven she stuck a slate-pencil into her ear, an accident that caused permanent brain damage. At an early age she began to show signs of dissolute conduct and to engage in prostitution. In November 1834, her mother had her confined in the Charitable Institution for Female Penitents, a home established and run by Agathe-Henriette Huguet, dit Latour. But far from improving, Maria’s behaviour led to her expulsion in March 1835; she was pregnant by then.
Maria ran off to the United States. There she found herself at the centre of an anti-Catholic nativistic controversy that had reached a peak when a mob set fire to the Ursuline convent in Charlestown (Boston) on 11 August 1834. In October 1835, a New York newspaper published a statement by Maria describing her life as a nun at the Hôtel-Dieu of Montreal. She claimed that on the order of the superior and of the auxiliary bishop, Jean-Jacques Lartigue, she had had to kill a companion who refused to submit to the revolting demands of the priests. The article announced the forthcoming publication of a “complete and detailed account” of the scenes at the Hôtel-Dieu.
In January 1836, Awful Disclosures of Maria Monk, a work that she was supposed to have written, came out in New York. In it were described the infamous things she claimed to have suffered as a Catholic nun. On 13 February 1836, Alfred-Xavier Rambau, editor of the Montreal paper L’Ami du peuple, de l’ordre et des lois, noted the recent publication of the volume, which he termed “as dull as [it is] untruthful.”
The immediate success of the publication brought out the truth about the real authors of this fabrication, for there was soon a dispute over the division of the profits. Evidence in court revealed that Reverend William K Hoyt, a determined foe of Catholicism, had helped Maria in her flight to the United States, and that the Awful disclosures had been written from Maria’s oral account by the Reverend John Jay Slocum, a Presbyterian minister, with the assistance of Hoyt, the Reverend George Bourne, and others, who had pocketed most of the profits from this best-seller.
In the autumn of 1836, another fugitive, Sister St Frances Patrick, who said that she too came from the Hôtel-Dieu, turned up in New York at just the right moment to substantiate these sensational revelations. She had been a nun at the same time as Maria and claimed to be able to corroborate each of her assertions. The two appeared at a public meeting and, after embracing effusively, conversed for some time about their stay together at the Hôtel-Dieu.
In 1838, Maria had a child by an unknown father, this time without attributing the paternity to a priest. Shortly afterwards she married, but through her habitual drunkenness and debauchery, she squandered her husband’s savings, and he soon left her. In 1849 she was arrested in a house of ill repute for having stolen money from the man she was entertaining, and she was incarcerated in a New York prison. Half mad, she died there in the summer of 1849.
Maria Monk remains the sad heroine of a volume that American historian Ray Allen Billington says was “important as sensational propaganda against Catholicism.” According to his estimate, 300,000 copies of Awful Disclosures were sold before the Civil War.

No comments:
Post a Comment